Is a Private Attorney Better Than a Court-Appointed Attorney?

Consideration was given for the editing and publication of this post.

The decision to hire a private attorney or court-appointed attorney is crucial and can have lasting ramifications on your life. If you or a loved one is facing criminal charges, it may seem like a given that they need an attorney. Is this true? What if the defendant can’t afford one? These are fair concerns, and while having an experienced defense attorney isn’t a requirement in most cases, it absolutely can help your case. Lane, Hupp, & Crowley explains types of sex crimes when hiring a private attorney could be necessary.

This post will cover what a private attorney is and how they differ from court-appointed attorneys. Consider this your go-to guide if you’re looking for information on hiring legal counsel in the event of criminal charges. 

Who Is a Private Attorney?

Private attorneys are defense lawyers who work on a client-by-client basis. These are the people you would call if you had the money to pay for their services but can also be hired through public or private programs. Their salaries come from clients and not the state. 

A private attorney has a license to practice law. They can also be a member of the bar association in your area. Bar associations are responsible for ensuring that their members follow certain standards and are competent in their jobs. When your local bar association finds an attorney negligent or incompetent, they’ll usually handle the punishment themselves.

Court-Appointed Attorneys

If you can’t afford an attorney on your own, you may be assigned a court-appointed attorney. Local courts or judges often assign defense attorneys to cases that don’t have a private attorney or when the defendant doesn’t have the financial means to pay for one.

Court-appointed attorneys represent people who are underprivileged and have limited access to legal representation. These lawyers take on cases that the government believes have merit but may not afford a lawyer for. They provide the same services as an attorney would but may not have extensive experience with certain areas of law, such as criminal defense or corporate law. 

Private Attorneys vs. Court-Appointed Attorneys: Who Should You Pick?

The answer to that question depends on what you’re looking for. If you want to be guaranteed a certain level of service, then you should choose a court-appointed attorney. However, if you can pay for private attorney services, it is highly recommended that you do so. The reason for this is simple: private attorneys often offer better representation and are often able to get your charges reduced. This can help you avoid going to jail or paying expensive fines. For these reasons, it’s always best to choose a private attorney when you’re in charge of your own fate and have the freedom to do so.

Differences from Public to Private

There are several major distinctions between public attorneys and private attorneys. The first is simply price. Private attorneys typically charge a much higher rate than the average public attorney. Several other factors determine the price, like experience, education, location, and title within the firm. It is also true that in many cases, legal fees can be costly to pay for a private attorney as opposed to paying your court debt with fines or serving time in jail.


Although there are many differences between public representation and private attorney representation, there are also several important similarities. Many states require that all defendants have someone represent them in court by their side during the trial process. This usually means an appointed attorney, but there may be times when you may be able to select your own private attorney instead of having to accept the court-appointed one. 

You need to take advantage of this option as it gives you the freedom to choose your own lawyer. This could potentially give you a better chance in the courtroom. Overall, the main difference is that you can better choose your private attorney as opposed to accepting a court-appointed one.

How do I find a local Lawyer if I Want Private Representation?

Criminal cases can have some of the most serious consequences for someone’s future, so hiring an experienced lawyer who has handled similar cases for other people in your area is very important.

If you have been charged with a crime, it is important to hire a criminal defense attorney as soon as possible. The earlier you seek the services of an attorney, the more likely that your rights will be protected and that you will be treated with fairness.

Choosing the right criminal defense lawyer is a vital step on the journey towards justice and safety. A qualified, experienced attorney can be your first line of defense against convictions, lengthy jail sentences, or other life-altering consequences.

When you are looking for a criminal defense lawyer, there are several things you should look for:

Right Credentials -Most states require a law degree in order to be licensed as an attorney. If your state’s particular requirements are not education-based, then a criminal defense lawyer should be able to demonstrate in other ways that they’re qualified to handle your case.

Experience – this can mean different things depending on the nature of the charges or the particular circumstances under which you were charged with a crime. The important thing to remember is that experience matters. The more experienced a criminal defense lawyer is, the better job they can do for you. It may be hard to tell how much experience a criminal defense attorney has, but there are some things you can look for. 

An attorney with experience should have references and/or testimonials from previous clients that you can contact and speak with about their experience with the attorney to help make your decision.

Right Temperament – Being calm and confident is key to a successful criminal defense case. The attorney should be empathetic but not overly emotional or apologetic. Be wary of attorneys who offer up too much information about your situation. The lawyer you choose must know how to keep information to themselves until the time comes for it to be shared.

A criminal defense attorney should have a clear picture of what it means to be charged with a criminal offense. They should understand the collateral consequences that can occur as a result of facing a criminal accusation. Simply put, they should be able to empathize with you and your situation.